Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof: 2023 Cost Analysis

Written by

Leroy Whitt

You know you’re officially a homeowner when you start seriously thinking about very exciting things like metal roofs.

When it’s time to replace your roof, one of the most crucial decisions you’ll face is whether to go with a metal roof or stick to traditional shingles. Understanding the cost implications of these choices is quite important, especially if you’re on a strict budget.

So, let’s take a deep dive into the cost of metal roofs vs. shingle roofs. We’ll look at different types of metal roofs, as well as various metal materials. We’ll also break down the cost considerations for 3-tab asphalt shingles and architectural shingles, helping you make an informed decision that aligns with your budget and preferences.

The Economics of Roofing: A Breakdown of Costs

Before we delve into the specifics of metal and shingle roofing costs, it’s essential to grasp the factors influencing these costs. These include:

• Quality of the material
• Complexity of the installation
• Size and slope of your roof
• Local labor costs
• Insulation and ventilation

Being aware of these factors will allow you to evaluate roofing estimates more effectively. You’ll also want to make note of any additional features you want that could add to the final cost, such as a new gutter system.

Additionally, sometimes the plywood roof deck has rotted and requires replacement. Roofing contractors aren’t always able to tell if this is the case until they start tearing off your old roof, exposing the roof deck below. If your roof deck needs replacement, this will also add to the final cost, regardless of the material you choose.

Exploring Metal Roofing Costs

Simply put, metal roofs are more expensive upfront than shingle roofs. But they also last at least twice as long. While shingle roofs usually last 15-25 years, metal roofs can last 40-70 years. So while the upfront cost is more expensive, many people justify metal roofing by knowing they won’t have to replace their roof again.

Types of Metal Roofs

There are different styles of metal roofs, and each of them comes with different cost considerations. Understandably, more aesthetically pleasing styles come with a higher price tag, and simple styles are more affordable. Let’s take a look:

Standing Seam Metal Roofs

The epitome of contemporary roofing, standing seam metal roofs are known for their durability and sleek appearance. However, this premium quality comes with a higher price tag. On average, you might expect to pay anywhere from $9 to $14 per square foot for standing seam metal roofs. The extra expense reflects the meticulous installation required and the long-term value these roofs bring to your property.

Corrugated Metal Roofs

If you desire a robust and distinctive roofing solution without stretching your budget, corrugated metal roofs could be your answer. Their rough-and-tumble aesthetic comes at a more reasonable cost, averaging between $4 and $7 per square foot. It’s a choice that balances durability and economy.

Metal Shingles or Tiles

Blending the charm of traditional shingles with the endurance of metal, metal shingles offer diversity in style and cost. You can anticipate prices ranging from $7 to $10 per square foot. The investment pays off with their impressive lifespan and visual appeal.

3 Metal Materials & Their Cost Per Square Foot

Beyond styles, metal roofing is also available in different materials. Some materials are more affordable upfront, while others are considered to be premium— and come at a premium price.

1. Aluminum

Known for its corrosion resistance and lightweight nature, aluminum roofing presents a mid-range option in terms of cost. The price hovers around $7 to $12 per square foot, making it a popular choice for homeowners seeking a balance between quality and budget.

2. Steel

The embodiment of strength and durability, steel roofs often fall within the range of $6 to $11 per square foot. They stand as a testament to longevity while offering value for your investment.

3. Copper

If you’re aiming for a roofing material that’s not only an investment but also a statement, copper is the best choice. Boasting exceptional weather resistance and a distinctive appearance, copper roofs command a premium price of $15 to $20 per square foot. It’s a decision that speaks volumes about your home’s elegance. Due to the high price, many homeowners will opt for copper features (like gutters) instead of full roofs.

Shingle Roofing Cost Considerations

Now, let’s take a look at the cost considerations of an asphalt shingle roof. Asphalt roofs are the most common roofing material in the country, mostly because they offer decent durability for a lower upfront cost. If you’re planning on selling your home within the next 10 years, shingles could be the more economical choice.

Types of Shingle Roofs

There are two main types of shingle roofs: 3-tab and architectural shingles. Each comes with a different upfront price.

• 3-Tab Asphalt Shingles: The quintessential choice for cost-conscious homeowners, 3-tab asphalt shingles provide reliable protection without straining your wallet. With prices averaging between $2 and $4 per square foot, they serve as an economical entry point into roofing.
• Architectural Shingles: Stepping up in terms of both quality and cost, architectural shingles offer enhanced durability and aesthetic appeal. Coming in at $3 to $5 per square foot, they offer a balance between affordability and longevity, as they often last longer than 3-tab shingles.

Cost of Metal Roofs vs. Shingle Roofs: The Verdict

In the battle of metal roof vs. shingle roof costs, the right choice hinges on aligning your budget with your priorities. While metal roofs present a higher initial investment, their endurance and long-term savings often justify the expense. On the other hand, shingle roofs cater to varying budgets, with architectural shingles presenting a fantastic compromise between cost and quality.

Remember that the figures mentioned here serve as general estimates and can vary based on factors unique to your location and project. As you make your decision, consider not only the immediate cost but also the extended benefits and savings your chosen roof will provide over its lifespan.

Whether You Want a Shingle or Metal Roof, We Can Help!

Maybe this blog left you feeling confident in your decision one way or the other. Or maybe you still need more professional advice before making a decision! If you live in Georgia, Whitt’s Quality Roofing has the expertise to install both metal and shingle roofs. We’d be happy to walk you through all the considerations and find the best solution for your home.

Give us a call today to learn more!